Show, don’t tell. I can assume all writers know this as Writing 101. Whenever I failed to comply with this rule, my manuscript would come back with red markings. My mentors always told me to use metaphors, similes, or strong verbs/adjectives to describe what we perceive with our five senses without telling the obvious.
My mentors guided me through the learning process: I trusted their advice. But, did that mean I had to forget about my instincts? Through this process, I accepted their suggestions blindly because I was afraid of stumbling along the way. However, all that changed when I started trusting that little voice inside of me: my instincts. One of my mentors had suggested deleting a few sentences and changing some words in my final draft. I didn’t. These sentences spoke loudly; they vibrated in my skin. My instincts were right. My story got published.
After an hour, my senses were heightened: I started distinguishing my server’s voice among the cacophony of sounds. My hands were quick to learn the objects around me. My hearing clearly made out what instruments the band was playing (The members of the band are also visually impaired, and are aptly called, Les ombres, The Shadows). Although my server guided me to our table, my other four senses guided me at the table (and I’m happy to share there were no incidents).
I wanted to share this amazing experience and use it as an analogy because I realized that whether we’re guided in our writing journey or not, we ultimately have blind faith in our instincts.
Do you trust your inner voice when you write?
A very cool and useful analogy.
ReplyDeleteI would be a little hesitant to eat there if they served alcohol. Could you see at all?
Hi Jeremey,
DeleteNope. We couldn't even see our own hand in front our face. They serve alcohol. If you order a bottle of wine, like we did, the server brings the glass already full. You don't need to fill up your glass ;)
Thanks for stopping by.
A nice, erudite post cleverly touching on the two topics of the senses. Firstly, O Noir, are very clever; by reducing your visual dependency the other senses heighten the culinary experience, so the food smells more intense and the flavours jump out at you, whilst your mouth works in concert with your imagination regarding the food textures. So very, very clever.
ReplyDeleteAs for relying on instinct with writing? Hell yes! I love, honour and respect my gut instinct. It's served me so very well through my life so far. And the more you trust it and listen to it, the better it gets.
So when writing, listen to your instinct, feel the words, live the moment as your character, because you and only you, truly know the reason behind the words in front of you. Okay, they might need trimming, or rearranging slightly, but the essential essence of what you want to convey should always remain. You as the author gave life to those words, have faith in them, let them breathe and grow. Ultimately, they have the potential to develop into something far bigger and greater than you hoped.
Feel the moment, see it, hear it, be it. If your writing does that for you, then it will do it for others. Readers want to forget they are reading. Move them, stimulate them, transport them. Turn their inner voice from lumpy porridge to golden, smooth honey. Take them on a journey they wish to return to time and time again.
Trust in your instinct to take them there and be their guide.
Apologies for the waffling :)
Hi Mark,
DeleteYes, I do agree. It's true we need someone else to point out our mistakes (that's what editors are for). However, the essence of the story, we have to know what's right for it, what works or not. I let my mentors guide me in the rough draft(s) but in the final draft, I decide which sentences/paragraphs stay or go. ;)
Great article. I agree when it comes to following our instincts and writing....like anything else in life. I myself had the same experience with an editor. She wanted me to edit out a large part of a novel I was writing which horrified some of my young readers as they claimed that that particular part of the chapter was what made the story more real. So, I listened and am glad I did!
ReplyDeleteHow sweet is that? Your young readers had the final say in it, and yes, your instincts told you that that part was essential. Glad it worked out for you! :-)
DeleteYes! Always! :-)
ReplyDeleteI used to blindly - seriously - follow all suggestions with regards to my writing when I first started and got thoroughly confused!! But it was more the type of stories I write. I am totally in love with all things paranormal and when I started years ago, I was told - there's no market for such things, write romance or litfic and I did but I felt my writing was very false and very forced.
But although I continue to be very grateful for the grammatic pointers my CPs/mentors continue to show me, I stick to the themes I prefer to write about.
That restaurant you went to sounds amazing btw!!! Take care
x
Hi Jennifer,
DeleteYes, the restaurant itself, well, it was pitch-black so we couldn't see anything. However, the overall experience was stimulating and unique.
If you write about something you're not fond of, it'll show throughout your story. Your readers would probably sense that your heart wasn't in it. Good for you, for sticking to your guns ;-)
That restaurant sounds fantastic! Oh to live in Montreal...
ReplyDeleteHi Wayne,
DeleteYes, we had fun indeed. Montreal has an eclectic restaurant selection. :D
Do you trust your inner voice when you write? Absolutely. Not always but often its a case of the blind leading the blind with 'critters' and all too often rules are brandished slavishly. A case in point - and which I've pinched from the horror writer Ramsey Campbell - is the use of the adverb. Ramsey highlights the misuse of:“I love you,” he said affectionately. Then, in contrast points out where the adverb adds something eg. “I love you,” he said bitterly. Similarly there is a case for 'telling' in some circumstances. In short 'rules' are great for guidance and to make you think twice, but ultimately, with experience and hopefully not misplaced confidence you have to follow that 'voice'
ReplyDeleteHi Mike,
DeleteOh yes! the dreaded adverbs ;) My mentor has warned me about those as well. Some people abuse the use of adverbs, creating a weak MS, hence, boring the reader. In my case, time has taught me to trust my instincts when I write. When I first started, I was overwhelmed listening to several people's suggestions, and not once, listening to my inner voice. That has changed though ;)
You're so right, Claudia. Sometimes it's best to leave those sentences in.
ReplyDeleteI'm interested to hear of your experience at O Noir. I wrote about them for a Vietnamese travel magazine two years ago. I had feedback from several readers who couldn't believe that such a place existed, or that one could eat in the dark. I like the analogy to writing and trusting your instincts.
Hi Chris,
DeleteThank you. I'll send you an email with more details ;)
Your time at O Noir sounds like a fantastic experience! And it's also a great analogy of trusting the intuition while writing.
ReplyDeleteI can't write without my inner voice, Claudia. That is what guides me!
Thanks for the awesome post.
Hi Raquel,
DeleteAwww! Thank you for your kind words. From what everyone has shared, it seems that we, writers, do trust our inner voice no matter what. Isn't that amazing? :D
What a different restaurant!
ReplyDeleteI'm not sure if I completely become my inner voice, or shut it off. It's hard to tell. I'm someone else when I'm writing.
Hi Dan,
DeletePerhaps you don't even realize when your inner voice is in silent mode ;) I bet it's guiding you from beginning to end.
I have to go to O Noir some day! When I was younger and needed to get up at night, I used to not turn on the light and walk in the dark; I had lived in my house all my life: I didn't need my eyes to know where I was going. Had just to rely on my senses. I'd invariably bump into something and wake up my mom, who'd say, annoyed: "Turn on the "°°*+* light!!".
ReplyDeleteI believe instincts are very important and, sometimes, they're a good enough justification not to follow someone's dear advice.
I really agree with your mentors: I believe true writing should not tell, but it should convey a subtext, giving the readers, through rhetoric devices, the chance to read between the lines.
A great thought-provoking post Claudia!
I like your style :)
Hi Jay,
DeleteI know you're an actor, so I wonder if this applies to actors as well. By the way, I am with your mom ;) I bet I would have said the same thing, LOL!
Odd. I never thought about it before. I'd always managed my business by instinct. Then a Corp. took over. I'd always maintained a 6% sales increase, a very low turnover and great profits. Then they went by a statistical analysis procedure and made hiring decisions from a different state. The business went to hell. I wonder if that's why I started writing?
ReplyDeleteOH, Dan! I'm sorry to hear that. I don't know anything about business, so maybe instincts in this field are not appreciated/used as much as in writing. :(
DeleteWell, something good came out of it, right? You're exploring your creative side. :D
Claudia: I love how you draw the analogy between your experience at O Noir and having faith when you write. Something in what you say resonates with me around trusting my intuition. I'm confronting that very aspect of both my writing and my coaching these days as my two passions are intersecting in a play I am preparing that chronicles my journey through learning life coaching. Lovely post!
ReplyDeleteHi Kelly,
ReplyDeleteThank you for sharing your thoughts on trusting your instincts. Good luck on your life coaching journey.
What a great post. Love reading about writer's processes for getting the finshed product of those awesome books!
ReplyDeleteThank you! Yep! We all learn from each other and that's really cool ;)
DeleteOMGoodness! That is a real place! They did a skit about it on Saturday Night Live.
ReplyDeleteI believe you have to trust your instincts. I think at first we all lean on our critique partners or teachers, but as we mature as writers we come to trust ourselves. :)
Hi Sharon,
DeleteDefinitely! I still trust what my mentors tell me and I let them guide me but in the end I trust my inner voice when it comes to the final edit ;)
Nice analogy, and your post is thought-provoking. That restaurant sounds really cool. What a great experience!
ReplyDeleteHi Dawn,
DeleteThank you for stopping by. Well, I cannot tell you what the restaurant look like inside because they never turned the lights on ;) but the experience was amazing!
Wow! What an awesome post. I really like your insight into following your instincts and believing in yourself, especially when it comes to writing. I am very intuitive and sensory when it comes to writing my own stories. I do my best to listen to my own voice most of the time. :) Also, that restaurant sounds amazing! I'm intrigued. Reminds me of that television series called Dating in the Dark. The participants would meet in a pitch black room and get to know each other by sound, touch, smell, etc. Only after they made the decision would they get to be allowed to see each other in light. I don't think the show aired long but it was fun to watch. What a great post! Thanks so much for sharing.
ReplyDeleteI have nominated you for the Sunshine Award! Visit this link to collect: http://melissakline.blogspot.com/2012/04/sunshine-award.html
Keep spreading sunshine, Claudia! :)
Hi Melissa,
ReplyDeleteThank you for sharing your thoughts on following your instincts. I never saw that show but I recall Joel McHale from the Soup, making fun of the show. ;)
Thank you so much for the award! I'll hop over your blog to learn more about it.
Thanks for your kind words and the nomination!
Great advice. Yes, I believe in following your instincts about what works for your own stories and novels, and what doesn't. All the other advice is good, and I certainly think you need to know rules before breaking them, but I also think that writing isn't like a recipe -- and even great cooks know when to follow their hunch.
ReplyDeleteHi Elizabeth,
ReplyDeleteOh, I love your analogy about writing and recipes ;)
I tend not to follow recipes to a tee. I always give it my own twist :D
Hope you feel better soon. I always trust my inner voice when I write. I believe in intuition as well.
ReplyDelete